Meeting was called to order by Minnesota Co-Chair Phil Monson at the Minnesota
Pollution Control Agency. Board members in attendance: Dorothy Anway,
Jack Ezell, Gail Gilliland, Rick Gitar, Phil Monson, Barb Peichel, Kinnan
Stauber, Nan Stokes, Diane Thompson. Members present introduced themselves.
Healthy Harbors: Restored Rivers:
Jennifer Feyerherm of the Sierra Club gave a very informative presentation
on a new publication she has been working on titled "Healthy Harbors,
Restored Rivers: A Community Guide to Cleaning Up Our Waterways."
This guide is designed to explain the steps necessary when attempting
to remediate an area with contaminated sediments.
She explained some of the initial information to gather before starting
the project such as assessing the problem, determining the types and extent
of the contamination, getting community involvement, analyzing an overarching
issues such as cycling and recontamination possibilities, choosing a strategy,
looking at costs, benefits, goals, risks etc.
She then went into some detail explaining the options for treatment including
Natural Recovery, Capping, In Place Treatment, and Dredging, covering
both the pros and the cons of each type of treatment. She finished by
explaining disposal options for any removed sediment, such as landfilling,
treating to remove toxins, dewatering, Thermal desorption and reduction,
vitrification and immobilization. She explained that situation should
be analyzed, as the best solution in one case may be detrimental in another
case.
The report is free. You can request a copy by writing the Sierra Club's
Midwest Office, 214 N. Henry Street, Suite 203, Madison, WI 53703-2200.
Business Meeting:
Minutes of the March 27, 2002 meeting were approved.
MN Attorney General's Charitable Organization Report:
A motion was passed to submit the report prepared by Lynelle and signed
by the co-chairs on the status of our organization.
Duluth Natural Area Program:
The CAC was asked to nominate a site for Duluth's proposed program to
designate areas as natural areas to be protected. The North Bay, located
upstream of Boy Scouts Landing and before Perch Lake was looked at by
the executive committee and was chosen as a good first site to be nominated
by the CAC.
Designation by the City will mean that the area will have a management
plan. This will be an excellent way to promote the habitat plan and to
get the recommendations of the plan incorporated into the City's management
plan for North Bay.
A motion was approved to have the CAC nominate North Bay for this special
designation.
GAO wrap-up:
The GAO issued a report to congressional requesters (Oberstar was one)
on the progress of EPA and the RAPs to clean up the 26 Areas of Concern
(AOCs) in the Great Lakes. The report was very critical of the EPA as
seen from the title of the report "EPA Needs to Define Organizational
Responsibilities Better for Effective Oversight and Cleanup of Contaminated
Areas." The report concluded that EPA is responsible for ensuring
these areas are cleaned up, but no office in the EPA is currently responsible
for overseeing it. Progress has been very limited. EPA has cut funding
and staffing for program related activities and shifted its focus to other
areas. The report recommends that EPA clarify which office within the
EPA is responsible and identify actions, time periods, and resources needed
to help EPA fulfill its RAP oversight responsibilities.
The entire report is available on the GAO website (www.gao.gov), report
number GAO-02-563.
Habitat Workgroup Report:
The habitat plan is very close to final. Deadline for expenditures is
Friday, May 24.
Contaminated Sediment Workgroup Report:
This group is still exploring new approaches to revive the workgroup without
diluting the issues.
Stewardship Group:
Annual cleanup at Wisconsin Point on March 27 was very successful. Volunteers
braved the cold, wind and rain to collect 50 thirty-five gallon and 35
industrial size bags of garbage. A burned wheelchair was the most unique
item collected.
The canoe trip is scheduled for Aug 17th. This time it will start at Boy
Scout Landing and end at Billings Park with the picnic. Voyageur canoes
will be available again. Volunteers are needed to help make this a success.
Newsletter Group:
The second copy of the newsletter is close to completion. It should be
ready for mailing by the beginning of June.
We are always looking for stories and/or ideas for the next newsletter.
Anyone wishing to contribute to the newsletter can contact Phil Monson
at monson.phil@epa.gov or (218) 529-5188.
Finance Workgroup:
The Finance workgroup will be meeting in June. They are facing challenges
due to budget cuts and reduced funding from state and government agencies.
Anyone interested in exploring future funding opportunities is invited
to contact Jack Ezell (218-722-3336) for meeting times.
Director's Report:
Habitat plan is almost completed. This is a culmination of 14 years of
work and is something everyone in the CAC can be proud of. There is a
wealth of technical and scientific information in this document and it
is only a start. It will be Phase one, covering the lower part of the
river. The next phase will cover the upper portion.
The members-only activities are going well. The next activity is fishing
with Dennis Pratt on June 1. All members are encouraged to attend.
The State of the Waters Conference was an excellent event attended by
Lynelle. Anyone interested in attending in the future would find it well
worth his or her time.
In September Lynelle will entertain 25 journalists that are hoping to
learn more about the St. Louis River and get a real feel for the issues.
Diane Thompson, Secretary